The
primary concern of our research group is to understand the dynamic
interplay of protein interactions in multicomponent ABC transporters,
taking the maltose transporter in E. coli as a paradigm.. We also
make phylogenetic studies on the superfamily of ABC systems.
The ATP-Binding Cassette
(ABC) superfamily is composed of systems that are widespread in
all living organisms. These systems form the largest family of paralogues
ever found. They are involved in a large number of living processes
including primarily but not only transport. In humans, 15 severe
genetic diseases including cystic fibrosis are caused by the dysfunction
of ABC transporters (Mourez et al., 2000). The transporters are
made of four structural domains: two very hydrophobic membrane spanning
or transmembrane domains (TMD) and two hydrophilic cytoplasmic nucleotide-binding
domains (NBD) peripherally associated to the cytoplasmic membrane
(Higgins, 1992). The primary sequence of the hydrophilic cytoplasmic
domains is highly conserved, displaying conserved Walker motifs
A and B common to ATPases and another motif characteristic of ABC
transporters, the LSGGQ or signature motif. These domains were found
to bind and to hydrolyze ATP, thereby coupling transport to ATP
hydrolysis (Schneider and Hunke, 1998). ABC transporters are involved in the export
or in the import of a wide variety of substrates ranging from small
ions to macromolecules. Import ABC systems are found only in prokaryotes
and their four constitutive domains are carried in general by independent
polypeptides. By contrast, export systems are found in all living
organisms and have in general the TMD's fused to the NBD's.
ABC import systems are also called binding protein-dependent (BPD)
transport systems(Boos and Lucht, 1996) (Saurin and Dassa, 1994). In addition to the basal core structure
of ABC transporters, they require for a proper function an extracytoplasmic
substrate-binding protein, located in the periplasmic space of Gram-negative
bacteria. BPD transporters are scavenging systems, able to extract
trace elements from the environment. The ABC maltose import
system of Escherichia coli is a model of ABC transporters. Its functional
characteristic are investigated in our group since the early 70's
(Hofnung, 1974). We contributed significantly to the physiological,
genetic and more recently to the molecular characterization of this
system. A working model consistent with these studies is currently
tested in our laboratory. According to this model, maltose and maltodextrins
enter the periplasm by facilitated diffusion through a specific
outer membrane porin coded for by the lamB gene, which is specifically
required for maltose transport at sub-micromolar concentrations
and for maltodextrins at all concentrations (Szmelcman and Hofnung, 1975). In the periplasm, maltose-binding protein
(MBP) binds substrates at high affinity (KD = 1 ???. Upon binding
of substrates, MBP undergoes a conformational change (Szmelcman et al., 1976) and interacts with a cytoplasmic membrane
complex made of MalF, MalG (Dassa, 1993; Dassa and Hofnung, 1985; Dassa and Muir, 1993) and two subunits of MalK (MalFGK2), very
likely with hydrophobic membrane proteins MalF and MalG (Hor and Shuman, 1993) that carry also a substrate binding site(s)
(Treptow and Shuman, 1985). Upon substrate binding, MBP transmits
through MalF and MalG a signal to MalK allowing it to hydrolyze
ATP (Davidson et al., 1992). The questions which are addressed in our
laboratory are the following: i) what are the sites on membrane
proteins for interacting with each others; ii) how does ATP binding
and hydrolysis result in conformational changes that mediate substrate
translocation across the membrane and iii) how do ABC systems evolved
and what are the rules that govern their functional diversity.
1. Interactions
between cytoplasmic membrane partners Integral membrane proteins of BPD transporters display
a short hydrophilic conserved motif, the EAA motif located at about
100 residues from the C-terminus (Dassa and Hofnung, 1985). The motif is hydrophilic and was found
to reside in a cytoplasmic loop (Saurin et al., 1994) so that it could constitute an interaction
site with the conserved cytoplasmic ABC subunits (Dassa and Muir, 1993). Mutations in conserved residues lead in
general to a transport negative phenotype (Dassa, 1990; Köster and Böhm, 1992). The different phenotypes of mutations
suggested that EAA regions were involved in two kind of interactions,
binding of NBD's to the membrane and transmission of functional
signals to NBD's. Suppressor mutations restoring transport were
found in the malK gene. They were mapped mainly into the so-called
helical domain. The conclusion of these studies are in favor of
the idea that EAA regions of TMD's are in close contact with the
helical domains of NBD's (Mourez et al., 1997). Hence, we propose that the EAA region-helical
domain interface would couple the energy of ATP hydrolysis to transport.
2. Conformational
changes linked to ATP hydrolysis
The interactions of NBD's with the TMD's were analyzed in vitro.
MalK was shown to bind to everted membrane vesicles made from a
strain lacking this protein and to reconstitute a functional system
for maltose transport and ATP hydrolysis (Mourez et al., 1998). MalK binding to vesicles was dependent
on the presence of MalF and MalG. ATP binding and hydrolysis were
shown to increase the binding of MalK, suggesting that its interaction
with MalF and MalG was tighter in the presence of nucleotides. When
incubated with nucleotides, MalK undergoes a large conformational
change, detected by changes in intrinsic fluorescence and in the
proteolytic pattern, that renders the helical domain accessible
to proteases (Schneider et al., 1995). We have shown that a single proteolytic
site, unveiled by ATP binding in purified MalK was not accessible
when MalK is reconstituted with MalF and MalG. This suggests that
the MalK helical domain would insert into the MalFG complex in the
presence of ATP, a notion which is consistent with the higher efficiency
of binding and with the observation that HisP and MalK were accessible
to proteases from the exterior of spheroplasts when the cognate
TMD's were present (Baichwal et al., 1993; Schneider et al., 1995). These studies strengthen the idea that
the helical domain of NBD's is crucial for interactions with TMD's
(Liu and Ames, 1998). We have investigated the proximity
of residues in the conserved EAA sequence of MalF and MalG to residues
in the helical segment of the MalK subunits by means of site-directed
chemical cross-linking (Hunke et al., 2000). The results suggest that residues A85,
K106, V114 and V117 in the helical segment of MalK, to different
extent, participate in constitution of asymmetric interaction sites
with the EAA loops of MalF and MalG. Furthermore, both MalK monomers
in the complex are in close contact to each other through A85 and
K106. These interactions are strongly modulated by MgATP, indicating
a structural rearrangement of the subunits during the transport
cycle. The number and the quality of contacts between residues of
the MalF-MalG EAA motifs and the MalK helical domain was increased
in the presence of ATP. Thus, it is tempting to speculate that the
observed changes in subunit-subunit interactions may reflect structural
rearrangements that are required to initiate ATP hydrolysis and
transport.
3. Evolution of
ABC systems in living organisms
We were among the first groups to analyze the sequence relationships
between constituents of ABC systems. The sequences of BP's display
very little overall sequence similarity in contrast with their closely
related tertiary structures. A careful sequence analysis of 52 BP's
revealed that they can be grouped in eight families of more strongly
related proteins (Tam and Saier, 1993). Remarkably, clustering of sequences was
in agreement with the chemical nature of the substrate. The degree
of sequence divergence was too high to establish rigorously that
all binding proteins are homologous, i.e. that they are of common
origin, but this idea is supported by their common structural organization.
TMD's are in general more conserved than BP's but it is nevertheless
difficult to demonstrate that they are homologous. It is possible
to group the proteins in clusters of strongly related sequences
and here also clustering reflects the substrate specificity of the
system (Saurin and Dassa, 1994). The clusters defined in such analyses
are strongly similar to those defined for substrate binding proteins.
All integral membrane proteins of BPD transporters display the EAA
conserved motif (Saurin et al., 1994). NBD's display a region of homology
that extend over 200 residues. A phylogenetic analysis of the sequence
of BPD transporters NBD's revealed that these proteins descend from
an ancestor protein (Kuan et al., 1995). Moreover the proteins segregate
into clusters strongly related to those found for TMD's and for
the BP's. This finding support the view that operons encoding partners
of BPD transporters evolved as a whole unit by duplication.. Since
similar BPD transporters are found in archaea and eubacteria, the
putative common ancestor of such systems appeared probably before
the separation of the two phyla, about 4 billions years ago. Recently,
by analysing about 200 NBD's from eukaryotes and prokaryotes, we
showed that ABC importers and exporters segregated in two different
groups of sequences, independently of their origin. This remarkable
disposition strongly suggests that the divergence between these
two functionally different types of ABC systems occurred once in
the history of these systems and probably before the differentiation
of prokaryotes and eukaryotes (Saurin et al, 1999). |